‘Paradise’ lost for euro crisis refugees

“In Spain they talk about Norway as a ‘paradise,'” 34-year-old Tatiania Espinosa told Norwegian Broadcasting (NRK), but the reality turned out to be much different. Espinosa is among the thousands of so-called “euro crisis refugees” who have fled 30 percent unemployment rates in Spain to seek a better life in Norway, only to see their dreams shattered.

New figures from state statistics bureau SSB show that the number of people from Greece, Italy, Portugal and Spain seeking work in Norway has now more than tripled, from 3,398 in 2003 to 14,414 last year. Work migrants from southern European countries hardest hit by Europe’s economic and euro crisis continue to travel to Norway, but the vast majority have a much harder time finding work than, for example, their counterparts from Poland and Sweden.

Language and network problems
Language is one major problem, since many lack not only any Norwegian training but don’t have a firm grasp of English either. Alexander Golding of Caritas Norge, a Catholic agency that tries to help new arrivals find jobs, told NRK Wednesday that they also lack the social networks of immigrant groups who are far more established in Norway. Caritas handled more than 7,000 applications for help last year alone.

Only the most highly educated within the fields of engineering and computer science have much luck finding good jobs in Norway, and many of them are recruited by Norwegian companies while still in their homelands.

Norwegian labour officials, also from the former left-center government, warned many of the work migrants who started arriving in larger numbers a few years ago that if they didn’t quickly find work in Norway, they should “go home,” because prospects were unlikely to improve. The competition for jobs, they claimed, is tough in Norway, too, despite the country’s strong oil-fueled economy.

Migrants holding EU citizenship that gives them work permission in Norway as well have continued to arrive, though, desperate to find jobs after finding it impossible to do so at home. “We’re still seeing a strong flow of work migrants coming from southern Europe,” Golding of Caritas told NRK. “Their prospects are poorer, even just socially, for making a living for themselves in Norway than for migrants from Poland and other Baltic countries.”

Moving around the country
SSB reported that work migrants, who earlier landed mostly in the Oslo area, are now spread over the entire country and have especially sought work in the west coast counties of Rogaland and Hordaland, both of which long have been buoyed by the oil and gas industry. Migration has also increased to the mountainous counties of Sogn og Fjordane and More og Romsdal, along with Sør-Trøndelag.

Many do find work on farms, in shipyards or the construction industry, but many also land in temporary low-paid cleaning jobs or as restaurant help, despite higher education. SSB reported that Rogaland, Møre og Romsdal and Finnmark in the far north of Norway had the highest levels of immigrant employment.

There are now a total of 317,838 immigrants in Norway with non-Norwegian passports, in a country of just over 5 million people. One of them, a middle-aged woman from Spain who didn’t want to reveal her name as she waited for help at Caritas, told NRK her family ran a business selling mobile phones and electronic equipment. When sales plunged and they finally had to close the shop, they traveled to Norway, hoping for a new start.

“There’s simply no work in Spain, it’s very difficult to survive there and we lost everything,” she told NRK. She’s had no luck finding work in Norway either, and claimed she’s willing to take on any kind of job now. Added another: “It’s not just an economic crisis in Spain, it’s a war among job seekers.”

newsinenglish.no/Nina Berglund

  • Tom Just Olsen

    Under the Red/Green government, from 2005 and onwards, some 300.000 new jobs were created in Norway. The vast majority within the private sector. 200.000 of these went to immigrants. Now unemployement is increasing slightly. First of all among immigrants:

    http://www.ssb.no/innvarbl/

    • frenk

      From 1978……
      What would they think of Labour Britain (or Norway) today. A country in which people ask: “Why work if you can get by without?”; “Why save if your savings are taxed away, or inflated away or both?”; “Why do a good job when you will probably make out just as well if you do a bad one?”; “Why bother to get extra qualifications when differentials and earnings so often depend on political muscle, not personal merit?”

      • Tom Just Olsen

        Indeed.
        The statistics speak for themselves. More people (of the total) take higher education and work in Norway compared to the UK.

        • frenk

          Yes….but what exactly are these people doing if your productivity has been flat-lining since 2007….and 200,000 of the jobs created were actually taken by ‘immigrants’? In ‘real-terms’ most of this employment will be low-skilled and low-paid….this does not actually contribute to the Norwegian economy because most of the cash ‘created’ will be moved abroad…and the taxation paid will pay for pensions/healthcare etc. later….
          Yes…if education is free…then why not continue…you will then enter a marketplace where you will have ‘very limited’ earning potential….

          • Tom Just Olsen

            More and more experts say that the fall in productivity since 2007 comes from ‘the building industry’. The only significant change there is that ‘the Poles’ have taken over all the rough jobs. This has led to less ‘planning’. Since it costs ‘almost nothing’ to let workers sit and wait. Within the building industry black labour and tax fraud is rampant.

            The majority of the immigrant workers go into low paid/low skilled jobs. Often people with high education. But if you can speak only Arabic – or English, you are not really qualified in Norway.
            I am dragging with a health issue that has made me a ‘frequent flyer’ within the health industry. What strikes me is all the immigrants. On both sides of the counter.

            Doctors of 2. generation Pakistani origin are quite common. They speak Norwegian just as good as I. But now I have met British doctors and a doctor from Chechnya, even. Both with accents, but speaking fluent Norwegian. More and more nurses comes from Sweden. They only have to ‘break the language’ a little to be understood.

            • frenk

              So why are Norwegians unable/unwilling to do the work….because the welfare system is ‘all too easy and profitable’…
              “In 2007 expenditures for disability and sickness benefits in Norway were 24 times higher than expenditures for unemployment benefits,” states Dr Hatland.
              “No other country has a higher proportion of recipients of health-related benefits than Norway and the imbalance in relation to unemployment benefits appears to be growing,” he explains.
              “For people without a job, the Norwegian welfare system makes it more attractive to apply for sickness or disability benefits than unemployment benefits. This is because individuals receiving health-related benefits have more rights and fewer obligations. Statistics show that practically no one returns to working life once they have been granted disability benefits.”
              http://www.forskningsradet.no/en/Newsarticle/Norwegian_welfare_system_facing_major_challenges/1253967894814?lang=en

      • frenk

        This is true today for Norway…and southern Europe….thank god I’m from the UK!!!

  • Maria

    What would you expect…? Even if we wanted to live in our countries, the labour market is actually violent – low salaries, many jobs dont give access to vacations, exploitation, “dictator” bosses, pressure, sorrow, pain, suffering, precarious jobs, unable to leave parents home, no access to outdoor life (unless you’re wealthy) or no future – despair! Many of us, southern europeans on our 30’s, after working hard and paying our studies, facing precarious jobs and unemployement again, and again, and suffering when there is only one life to live… And the years are passing by and no job, and i’ve never voted in those corrupts in the southern Europe governments…it’s excruciatingly painful! Years ago i just wanted to move to a smaller city in my country but there is no jobs anywhere here – and now around here there is a mass of so-called “unpaid internships” which are actually when a person is desperate!!! Of course that i wanted to live, i have to say, and even is with a pain in my heart i have to nearly implore to a swede or a norwegian that i want to live there…can you imagine how it is hard to say?… but MORE – to have been born in Norway or Sweden. This crisis already took a loved one’s life due to depression. Young norwegians study, go to work, go to hike in nature (something that i love and it is very distant to have in my country – you have to go everywhere by car and even tthen… you are NOT allowed to roam free in the wild!) It is embarassing to say, but YES i wish i was born in Norway on a norwegian family – and see my academic efforts and my work and dedication recognized… Because i really want to work, and this suffocating pain of being in imprisioned here and only crowded suburbs instead of vast forests. I already studied there in the North and i found out, besides housing and some basic bills (internet, phone, food, electricity…), i dont need much more than the basics, a suitable job – no riches, just sustainability…respect as a worker…and i dont really need much – with all that AMAZING NATURE around – be born a norwegian: what else could i, a nature passionate, wishing desperately for a job and some basic living – what else could i ever wnat?… :( Efforts? Will? Passions? Goals? No, it seems that the country you are born condemns you to death in life…and a slow, punishing one.